How We Handle a Section 143(2) Scrutiny Notice

Where the Assessing Officer (“AO”) selects a Return of Income for scrutiny, a notice is issued under Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act. In most cases today this falls under the Faceless Assessment Scheme — every notice, response and supporting document is exchanged electronically through the Income-tax Portal, with no physical interface between the taxpayer and the Department.

Why Professional Representation Matters

A scrutiny assessment is not a routine compliance exercise. The AO holds wide statutory powers to examine records, summon third-party information, and propose additions or disallowances to returned income. The quality, precision and timeliness of each submission directly determine the outcome. Engaging experienced representation delivers three decisive advantages:

Protection of your position. Every query is answered with verified facts, complete documentation and applicable legal authority — eliminating the inadvertent admissions and incomplete replies that most often lead to adverse additions.
Strategic control of the proceedings. We anticipate potential issues, prepare responses to address them proactively, and seek adjournments when timelines are unreasonably short — keeping the proceedings organised, timely and well managed.
Senior-level attention throughout. Experienced professionals handle every stage — analysis, drafting, legal research, documentation and representation — so your matter is presented carefully and effectively before the Income Tax Department.

How the Assessment Will Proceed

Scrutiny proceedings typically progress through the following stages. Multiple notices may be issued over the course of the assessment, which must be completed within the statutory time limit prescribed under the Act.

Stage	What It Involves
Notice under Section 143(2)	The statutory commencement of proceedings, requiring you to participate and furnish information and explanations as called for.
Notices under Section 142(1)	The AO requisitions books of account, records and explanations to verify income declared, deductions claimed and exemptions availed. Multiple notices may follow depending on the complexity of the case.
Written submissions	We prepare detailed responses to every query, supported by documentary evidence, statutory provisions and judicial precedents. Each draft is shared with you for review and approval before filing on the Portal.
Third-party verification	The AO may independently verify facts by issuing notices under Sections 131 and 133(6) to banks, employers or other parties. We monitor and address any resulting queries.
Show cause notice	If any addition or disallowance is proposed, the AO issues a show cause notice setting out the proposed adjustment. We prepare and file a detailed reply with supporting evidence and analysis of the applicable tax provisions and judicial precedents before any adverse view is taken.
Assessment order under Section 143(3)	The AO concludes the proceedings by determining total income and tax liability. Any tax demand is intimated through a notice under Section 156.
Appellate remedy	If the order is adverse, an appeal lies before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC) within 30 days of receipt of the order.

Scope of Work

A. Analysis and Documentation Review

Conduct an in-depth review of the return filed for the relevant assessment year, including the computation of income, Form 26AS, and the Annual Information Statement (AIS)/Taxpayer Information Summary (TIS).
Identify the issues raised in the Section 143(2) notice and anticipate points likely to arise in subsequent notices under Section 142(1).
Compile all supporting financial records — bank statements, Form 16/salary records, investment proofs, and receipts substantiating deductions and exemptions claimed.

B. Preparation of Responses to Notices

Draft clear, concise and factually supported responses addressing every query raised by the AO.
Annex relevant documentary evidence with each submission to demonstrate complete compliance and transparency.
Invoke judicial precedents supporting your contentions wherever they strengthen the legal position.

C. Submissions and Representation

File all documents and explanations within stipulated timelines, eliminating procedural defaults.
Respond to any discrepancies flagged by the AO promptly, with documents and legal references, to resolve issues at the earliest stage.
Where a notice allows less than 15 days for response, seek an adjournment so that every submission filed remains well-reasoned, complete and properly supported.

If you have received a notice under Section 143(2), the sooner we review it, the more options remain open.

Schedule a Consultation

← Back to Litigation Practice